Pages

Showing posts with label Hydroton. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hydroton. Show all posts

Sunday, 13 September 2015

Cocopeat Trial

Coco peat soil mix trial on my gutter set is not giving good result, it could be the type of plant that I tried.
Spearmint, on left with coco peat and right with hydroton. Both of these are in the same gutter growbed system.
Bawang Dayak, this in front compare to the one at the back which is in hydroton. The one in hydroton grow better.

These coco peat mix could be waterlogged in the flood & drain system. I will need to use pebbles next to provide alternative to hydroton.

Sunday, 11 August 2013

Hydroton Growbed Redo

One of the hydroton growbed giving me problem with its siphon. As I recall this particular growbed was the first that I tried with hydroton in my set.
Emptied the growbed and what needed to be done is to redo the siphon strainer. It was a quickie job few months back while I am trying out the hydroton. The strainer from start I know will eventually give problem.
During that time I was using 10 mm drill to make the strainer, but it was too big and letting hydroton through. As a temporary measure I glued plastic netting to make sure no hydroton  pass. Current design is 8 mm holes and no netting required.
Above the complete trouble siphon assembly, what needed to be done is to make 8 mm holes on the top and strainer holder as in current design.
Siphon removed from growbed to rework.
Smaller holes drilled and strainer holder is also drilled for water drainage. It was not done earlier, adding problem to the siphon operation.
Stand pipe and reworked strainer holder installed.
Completed siphon, bigger holes on top is not required. It is there because I reuse the same strainer to make smaller holes on the other side and just flip it over.
Old and new side by side for comparison, inner parts not change.
I decided to put first 2 ~ 3 inches with pebbles, they are better at drainage. Took me about 2 hours to redo and get it back operating. Hope it doesn't cause any problem to growbed nutrient level.

Monday, 25 February 2013

Hydroton Growbed - Part II

Top up additional bag of Hydroton today, so that makes it 4 bag for this growbed. RM 280.00 in total, its quite a sum to pay for a 3 x 2 grow area.



Looks good, let see in few more months how its doing on my setup. Now I'm letting it mature for the next 6 to 8 weeks. Will do simple plants first before it fully matured.

Saturday, 23 February 2013

Pebbles & Hydroton Comparo


This only comparison on price factor between Hydroton and Pebbles on my 3 ft Growbed the only different is the racking required.

Hydroton which is lighter will not need an expensive rack, while Pebbles do need it. I may try Pebbles on lighter rack later.




Below are items needed and it price.

Hydroton : 4 Bags @ RM 70 per bag so its RM 280.00 for a growbed
Racking : Sloted Angled Iron @ RM 70.00 (exclude man hour)
Total Cost : RM 350.00 per Growbed



Pebbles : 10 Bags @ 8.00 (Average price) so its RM 80.00
Racking : Custom Made @ RM 250.00 each (Average price)
Total Cost : RM 330.00 per Growbed




Price different is not that much, however if lower grade pebbles are use than the price would be around RM 6.00 per bag



If racking for Pebbles can be made of Slotted Angled Iron then it could be reduce in price more, than it would be much significant.

Using Hydroton the total price per growbed is around : RM 350.00 excluding other common item and Pebbles growbed will cost about RM 130.00 ~ RM 330.00 depending on racking and grade of pebbles.

Pros and Cons of Hydroton

Pros
  1. Light Weight
  2. Ph Neutral - This is one important factor.


Cons
  1. Expensive
  2. Limited retailer selling it
Pros and Cons of Pebbles

Pros
  1. Cheap
  2. Easy to get

Cons
  1. Heavy
  2. Ph on the high side - This is bad.
I will compare after few months how Hydroton holds up to Pebbles.

Update 21 July 2015

Without doubt hydroton is much better to be use in Aquaponics due to its neutral Ph and light weight. It is very easy to work with making the process of setting growbed much easier.

Pebbles, due to its heavier weight makes redoing growbed or setting up very tiring. The racking for pebbles are expensive offsetting the cheaper price of pebbles.

Currently I am trying to reduce on the amount of hydroton requires for setting aquaponics set by using Potted Media Base Flood And Drain NFT Hybrid. It is still in its trial phase and whether it is successful or otherwise only after few months of trial will tell.


Hydroton Growbed - My 1st Attemp

Another Growbed in the process of completion, this time I use Hydroton (LECA) to try out. I'll calculate the costing in comparison to stones or pebbles later : Here


 This time I use a strainer holder made of 110 mm PVC pipe endcap, compare to gluing strainer direct a strainer holder is easier to work with. However water remaining after siphon cut off will be half an inch more than the direct glued on.




Two gasket are used one on each side of this holder to prevent leak and please take note that this gasket at bottom try to use a thicker rubber due to sometimes the growbed tub is uneven and cause a leak.




 Above holder and stand pipe in place.



Water inlet I tap from existing pump, making it feed three growbed. No problem since this pump I am using has excess capacity.



Those Hydroton (LECA) are smaller in size, so my 10 mm holes strainer not able to handle it properly. A quickie additional strainer made of plastic netting fixed the problem.



Three bags of LECA is not enough, I'll get another bag. So 4 bag of LECA needed for each of my growbed.



Under Growbed plumbing, I don't have enough 25 mm PVC that the reason for stepping up to 40 mm. I need to change that to all the way 25 mm.



Friday, 22 February 2013

Hydroton Revisited

Got myself three bags of Hydroton to try out, should be enough for one growbed.



I never try planting with hydroton, my last experiment with it make me hold on to trying it out. Finally today these three bags will be the Guinea Pig for my Hydroton Growbed. At RM 70.00 per bag its quite a sum to pay, RM 210.00 for these 3 and just enough for one growbed.

Update : 4 bag of 50 Lt is required for Growbed below.

If I use stones or chip pebbles will only set me back about RM 70.00 for 10 bag that enough for same size growbed. Well I need to try, one advantage of Hydroton is its light in weight so, don't need strong racking.



At the same time I bought another two growbed tub, that the 3 feet Guppy Tank. This is for my Hydroton bed and the other one I'll turn into a fish tank to be use with another smaller growbed to test few things.

Will see how it turn out.

Tuesday, 23 February 2010

Hydroton - Simple Test

I am testing Hydroton usage in Flood and Drain Aquaponics, my previous trial was no good. I left a bucket full of Hydroton few weeks in a pail of water to see whether it will settle down, it did not.


This current test, I am conducting is a simple one. Hydroton in a jar soak in water, maybe this time it will sink to the bottom and use able in flood and drain Aquaponics.


I need to verified that Hydroton can be use in Flood and Drain Aquaponics and will update this post on the progress.